Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
An absolute steal
I'm a little embarrassed to admit that I actually only got round to playing the first Uncharted game, Drakes Fortune, a week or so ago. It'd been sat amidst my pile of shame for ages and only the imminent release of its sequel managed to propel it into my PS3. Better late than never however and after a few days and many happy hours play time not only finished it but I'd mentally installed it firmly in my top five games of the current generation. Interest now well and truly spiked for the arrival of Among Thieves I was intrigued to see how Naughty Dog could possibly improve on so complete an experience.
For anyone not up to speed at this point you once again take control of treasure hunting explorer Nathan Drake in a third-person action adventure game that combines exploration, platforming, shooting and puzzle solving into a single, satisfying gaming pie. It is a concept that's admittedly hardly original and it is not difficult to see the obvious influences that have inspired the Uncharted formula. Happily this never feels like a bad thing and rather than coming off as a clone Uncharted instead feels like Naughty Dog have cherry-picked the best bits from a number of sources and, more often than not, improved them to ensure Nathan does the whole Tomb Raider thing far better Lara ever has; but for the lack of hat, whip and license, this is the best Indiana Jones game ever.
This time out the game takes place a couple of years after the events of Drake's Fortune with Nathan and new love interest Chloe Frazer investigating the mystery of Marco Polo's doomed voyage home from China back in 1292. Throw in a magical Buddhist sapphire called the Cintamani Stone as well as the legendary kingdom of Shambhala, or Shangri-La as its better known and you've got a plot as steeped in ancient wonder and mystery as you could possibly want. To give any real detail would be to do the game a disservice as the plot is inevitably better experienced spoiler-free but suffice to say it's full of all the twists and turns you'd expect and will most definitely not disappoint.
While it's true to say that fundamentally Among Thieves is more of the same in terms of basic gameplay there's a very real sense that this time Naughty Dog feel confident enough to show off. Having proved their ability to craft a great game with Drake's Fortune they've taken this opportunity to ensue the experience is as close to perfect as possible. While the original game could at times feel a little like a non-stop cycle of combat and platforming without any real change of pace, everything here flows far more organically so that while its still made up of the same gameplay pieces the edges have been blurred sufficiently that you rarely see the joins anymore.
As fans of the original will remember, what elevated the game from being simply very good to genuinely fantastic was how natural controlling Nathan felt. Part of that was the constant sense that the game understood what you were trying to do and did its best to help you along. It was never done in a way that made you feel invincible or like it was cheating for you, it just did its best to make you feel safe enough in its hands not to worry about needing pixel perfect jumping all the time, et al. Thankfully little has changed in the control scheme for the sequel, Nathan still responds and reacts almost perfectly to both his surroundings and your input, doing his best to make you look good at all times, and he even has a few new moves to keep things feeling fresh. Most helpful of these is the ability to shoot while dangling single-handed from ledges, something that comes in handy far more here than it ever would have in the original, while some new stealth kills complete the improvements.
Although levels you'll be exploring are still firmly linear their design is clever enough that you rarely feel like you're being led by the nose. Instead the game expertly ensures that nine times out of ten you simply want to go the way it needs you to, meaning you don't really notice the dead ends and locked doors.
Combat was another area that didn't need any fundamental changes, the original's slick duck and cover system having stood the test of time admirably. One thing that has changed is that there's noticeably more verticality to the combat this time out. How much this is a natural evolution caused by the level design and how much is deliberate is hard to tell but it does make the action feel less formulaic as well as constantly keeping you on your toes.
One niggle carried over from the first game is the way enemies still appear in clearly unnatural waves. What looks like a clear area often suddenly has a new contingent of bad guys running into it just when you think it's safe to move on. On the one hand artificially spreading them out like this is better than finding a room filled with a huge number of enemies all at once but on the other it never feels natural, instead conjuring up images of bad guys hiding round corners just waiting until their friends have been shot.
Comments
ive been waiting for a game on the ps3 to bring me in
this is it nows the time to add the ps3 to the console stand
"......enemies hiding around corners waiting for their friends to be shot" made be laugh out so loud a simple lol wouldn't have done it any justice, it required a full sentence. :-)
I played the original uncharted through 4 times (3 to get all the trophies, and one just for fun before trophies were retro added) I'm counting the days to this sequel.
Pre-ordered. Can't wait. Looooved the first one.
Solid review, Paul.
I played the Uncharted 2 demo with just me and a mate to test it out. It is amazing! We then played with other people which was even better. The graphics are fantastic. I too, then started playing the first one again. I dusted it off, put it in my PS3 and now wish that I'd played it when I first got it. It's a really good game with a great story.
I can't wait to play the full version of Uncharted 2!
More morons that have been PS3 bashing without actually knowing anything about the system, what games there are, or anything about the games.
To admit that you review stuff, but never picked up Uncharted, yet publicly diss the PS3 nicely demonstrates hoe contrived and biased the media is...
Still I suppose at least you admit it, clearly some review sites (mainly American, Microsoft sponsored ones like Joystiq and Kotaku), don't review, print what they think people want to hear (or what Microsoft tell them to print), withouth playing the game.
It looks like the conspiracy has been discovered... by a commenter on our site. Who would have thought it. I'm very proud.
I so don't understand how Paul is "dissing the PS3" as Mark puts it. Didn't get that sense from the review. Not at all.
Also, what's wrong with not having played the original until a week ahead of playing the sequel? Ever heard of personal preference?
If, as a rule, Paul happens to enjoy other game genres more than third-person action titles, then the fact he gives Among Thieves a whopping 96% is testament to the game's impact.
I think Mark must be reading the alternate version of the review, the one where I hated it simply because it's a PS3 game and gave it only 10%...... Ho hum...
I'd have played Uncharted 1 much earlier were it not for all the other games I have to play for review purposes... Not that I'm complaining for a second, but there are only so many hours in the day... lol ;)
Extraordinary game ... extraordinary developers. Clearly GOTY, no doubt about that.
Paul, I can't believe you only got to play the first two weeks back! It was one of the gems in a period when genuine AAA PS3 games were still dry.
Now I'll be waiting to pick this one up, GOW3, Heavy Rain, Final Fantasy XIII & Final Fantasy XIII VS :)